Here is my brief review of the latest Spider-Man film. I am a huge nerd and a longtime fan of the comic books. I have an irrational affinity to Spider-Man stories and wanted to voice my response to the movie.
- Screenplay: Alternating between 9/10 (at times) and 2/10 (at times). Too many screenwriting cooks must be the reason for this spoiled broth.
- Directing: 7/10. Many moments are awesome and well-directed. Others are unintentionally hilarious. The inconsistencies were very distracting. The overall feel was excellent, however, and the essence of Spider-Man was conveyed far better than in any of the previous films.
- Editing: 10/10. I didn’t notice it.
- Scoring: 2/10. Distracting and inappropriate music through most scenes.
- Motion capture and CG animation: 10/10. Some of the best I’ve scene. Spider-Man’s movement was beautiful and life-like.
- Photography: 10/10. Loved it.
- Lighting: 10/10. One of the best-lit action films I’ve seen.
- Art department (sets, props): 10/10.
- Visual Effects: Alternating between 10/10 (Spidey’s sewer web-spinning scene) and 2/10 (the scene with the cheesy dialogue while the kid was escaping from the suspended car; the fake flames looked like a 1980s-era episode of Dr Who).
- Sound editing: 5/10. The slow-down sounds in the very last scene were a good example of how to ruin a movie with bad sound design.
- Andrew Garfield: 10/10. Incredible dialogue and physical acting. (Amazing performances by stunt artists as well.)
- Emma Stone: 10/10. Unexpectedly awesome chemistry between Gwen and Peter.
- Rhys Ifans: 3/10. Melodramatic. Unintentionally humorous performance.
- Martin Sheen: 8/10
- Sally Field: 7/10
- Denis Leary: 7/10
- Irrfan Khan: 2/10. Helped Rhys Ifans make some hilariously poor B-movie scenes.
Note to Mr Webb: Lizards smell with their tongues, not their nostril holes.
Note to audiences: Stay and watch the credits. There’s a bonus scene, but you should watch the credits anyway. Most people leave before the movie is over.